Richard Nixon, celebrating his election on Nov. 7, 1968, campaigned towards a backdrop of racial inequality, civic unrest and polarized politics. AFP through Getty Photographs

On this yr’s presidential election, phrases reminiscent of “legislation and order” and “the silent majority” have been heard pretty usually from Donald Trump and a few of his supporters.

These phrases hark again to an earlier presidential election, which befell in 1968. That one was a three-way affair involving former Vice President Richard Nixon, a Republican; incumbent Vice President Hubert Humphrey, a Democrat; and the third-party candidacy of a Southern segregationist, Alabama Gov. George Wallace.

As in 2020, the presidential election in 1968 befell amid city unrest, rising violent crime, racial rigidity, clashes between protesters and the police, and a excessive diploma of political polarization.

Regardless of these parallels, what actually stands out when one appears to be like again to the 1968 election and compares it with this yr’s are the variations, not the similarities.

Protesters have demonstrated in Portland, Oregon, since late Could to finish racial inequality and police violence.

Allison Dinner / AFP/Getty

Centrist alignment

Though the occasions of 1968 reminiscent of city riots, Martin Luther King Jr.‘s assassination, and the extreme preventing in Vietnam have been polarizing, the 2 main events stood a lot nearer collectively on most points than they do now.

In 1968, the Democrats as a complete have been a extra centrist social gathering, whose ranks included numerous conservative white Southerners in Congress in addition to in state and native places of work. These Dixiecrats, as they have been recognized, tended to counterbalance the affect of the social gathering’s Northern liberals.

The Republican Get together was additionally markedly extra centrist then, with numerous reasonably conservative voters and lawmakers who restrained the GOP’s so-called “motion conservative” wing.

The way more centrist orientation of the two-party system, then, can be seen within the presidential candidates the Democrats and the Republicans selected in 1968. Each have been quintessentially institution figures.

A line of Nationwide Guardsmen stand throughout from a gaggle of protesters throughout widespread demonstrations on the Democratic Nationwide Conference in Chicago in 1968.

Picture by Miriam Bokser/Villon Movies/Getty Photographs

The Democratic candidate, Hubert Humphrey, was in most respects a standard New Deal liberal, the type of FDR-inspired, pro-union, anti-Communist middle leftist whose formative political expertise was the Nice Despair.

GOP candidate Richard Nixon was greatest recognized for having served because the No. 2 man within the reasonably conservative Eisenhower administration. Though considerably totally different, these mainstream New Deal liberal and Eisenhower Republican viewpoints have been nonetheless nearer to one another than the types of liberalism and conservatism which can be dominant within the Democratic and Republican events right now.

The unbiased candidate that yr, George Wallace, was a disruptive and polarizing determine. He in the end completed a distant third within the race as a result of his operating mate, Normal Curtis LeMay, turned off voters along with his very hawkish rhetoric concerning the Vietnam Battle.

However the Wallace candidacy did have an effect on the election, as a result of his recognition within the South (the place he gained 5 states) raised the likelihood that no candidate would obtain an Electoral School majority, which might have thrown the election into the U.S. Home of Representatives.

The Wallace candidacy additionally made a distinction by contributing to the continuing erosion in help for the Democratic Get together amongst white Southerners, a pattern that finally reworked American politics.

In 1968, although, Wallace’s principal impact on the race was to draw votes that may have gone to Nixon, who consequently gained with solely a plurality – 43% – of the nationwide in style vote.

This three-way type of contest and its penalties are very totally different from this yr’s presidential race, which is basically a two-person race.

In 1968, there have been three distinguished presidential candidates; this yr, solely two.

Eva Marie Uzcategui / AFP/Getty photographs

Outdated appeals could not work

Among the most necessary points in 1968 have been additionally profoundly totally different from these of right now.

That yr, sharply rising inflation and the Vietnam Battle have been among the many most influential elements in deciding the end result. That’s in marked distinction to 2020, when inflation could be very low and no overseas coverage concern has something like the burden that Vietnam did in 1968.

And among the main points in 2020, such because the coronavirus pandemic, local weather change, well being care, excessive unemployment, immigration, commerce and the decline of the center class (which hadn’t but occurred in 1968), have been absent 52 years in the past.

Even 2020’s protests towards racial inequality and police brutality, in some methods just like those in 1968, are additionally totally different as a result of at the moment the main focus was on resistance to the outdated Jim Crow segregation system, not the much less overtly seen systemic racism rooted in financial inequality and mass incarceration.

[Get our most insightful politics and election stories. Sign up for The Conversation’s Politics Weekly.]

Testing the identical method

If 1968 and 2020 are such totally different election years, why have phrases related to the primary tended to crop up in President Trump’s marketing campaign speeches?

Trump, who turned 22 in 1968, is sufficiently old to recollect the 1968 presidential race, which was the primary one through which he may vote. He little doubt additionally remembers the attraction of Nixon’s “legislation and order” and “silent majority” themes amongst working-class and lower-middle-class white voters within the outer boroughs of New York Metropolis, the place he grew up. Though a lot of these voters have been traditionally extra oriented towards voting for Democrats, rising crime and concrete rioting elevated fears of Black folks amongst these sorts of voters. Nixon’s code phrases helped to drive them towards voting for Republicans.

Trump seems to be making an attempt to make use of that very same method this time, however given how totally different situations are in 2020 than they have been in 1968, it’s not clear that Trump’s techniques can have something just like the traction they did when Nixon used them.

David Stebenne doesn’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or group that may profit from this text, and has disclosed no related affiliations past their tutorial appointment.