Shutterstock

A UK citizen who has been dwelling in France for 36 years has introduced a case to the Court docket of Justice of the European Union that would have profound implications for British folks dwelling in European nations after Brexit. The girl is hoping to retain some citizenship rights after she ceases to be a European citizen.

British folks arguably misplaced their EU citizenship on January 31 when the UK ceased to be a member state. This modifications their rights on the subject of dwelling and dealing in EU nations – and even in travelling freely within the EU. When the Brexit transition interval ends on December 31 2020, a interval of main uncertainty begins.

The regulation isn’t easy. When the foundations on residents’ rights had been drawn up, it wasn’t with a view to figuring out what to do if a member state ever left the EU. Earlier than Brexit, EU residents would solely ever have been in peril of dropping their EU citizenship if their nationwide citizenship of an EU member state was withdrawn. This solely pertains to people who find themselves not EU residents by delivery and have both gained their citizenship by way of fraud or are jeopardising it as a result of they dedicated a criminal offense.

There have been efforts to convey the problem of the lack of UK-EU citizenry to the eye of the European court docket earlier than however they’ve failed. These circumstances have principally primarily based their argument on what known as the elemental standing of EU citizenship. That is the concept EU citizenship is a proper that can’t be arbitrarily withdrawn. That is one thing the European Court docket launched after which developed in its previous resolution making ever because the case of a French pupil who fought to be given entry to authorities advantages in Belgium. On this case the Court docket launched the concept “union citizenship is destined to be the elemental standing of nationals of the member states, enabling those that discover themselves in the identical scenario to get pleasure from the identical remedy in regulation no matter their nationality, topic to such exceptions as are expressly offered for”.

Within the context of Brexit, the argument is that British EU residents have completed nothing to warrant dropping their rights, even when the UK is leaving the union. Nobody has efficiently argued this case in court docket, nonetheless. Circumstances should be delivered to the European court docket by home courts, which hear circumstances after which ahead inquiries to the EU stage the place wanted. Claimants have by no means satisfied a nationwide court docket questions of their case must be despatched to the EU judicator – till now.

Disenfranchised?

On this French case, a UK citizen residing in France argues she mustn’t have been struck off the electoral roll for the French municipal elections held in March 2020. Voting and standing in regional and communal elections are rights inherent to EU citizenship. The French court docket is due to this fact asking the European court docket, amongst different issues, to make clear whether or not the Brexit withdrawal settlement, along with Article 50 needs to be understood to end result within the lack of EU citizenship for all former British EU residents.

The case has made it to the European courts.

Shutterstock

The reference to the European court docket additionally features a query on the standing of EU citizenship for a particular group of UK residents – those that have made use of their proper to free motion earlier than the top of the Brexit transition interval and have been settled in an EU member state for over 15 years. The timeframe is necessary, as it’s after 15 years that UK residents lose their proper to vote in UK elections.. If, as on this French case, these residents at the moment are dropping their voting rights of their host nation, they turn into politically disenfranchised.

The result will probably be significantly fascinating for the estimated 1.three million UK residents dwelling within the EU. Many will hope that Brexit doesn’t need to imply an finish to their rights.

The case argues that UK residents who’ve settled in an EU member state had the professional expectation that they might have the ability to keep there indefinitely. They legitimately assumed after they determined to to migrate from the UK that the rights that they had after they first settled would live on.

What occurs subsequent?

Within the best-case situation, the CJEU will present a transparent reply to the query concerning the lack of EU citizenship for UK residents overseas with a powerful “no”.

However in need of that, even just a few clarification about what is going to and received’t occur to those folks after Brexit can be welcome. A optimistic resolution by this court docket would make clear their standing, present them with safe residency, equal remedy and political rights, that will in any other case rely upon the state they selected as their new dwelling.

It could possibly be years earlier than the CJEU reaches a choice on this case, so it’s necessary for UK residents dwelling within the EU to not get their hopes up. On the similar time, they’re dwelling with none authorized certainty in any respect. The Brexit withdrawal settlement signed by the UK and EU says that member states want to make sure any UK residents dwelling of their territory can register for a brand new proper to stay. However usually, this new standing doesn’t evaluate to the elemental standing of EU citizenship. The rights it confers are minimal and don’t mechanically embody entry to healthcare. It’s as much as every member state to resolve what they need to supply, underneath which situations and for a way lengthy.

That’s why it’s value maintaining a tally of this case because it travels to the CJEU. It may supply far larger authorized certainty for UK nationals affected by Brexit.

Anne Wesemann doesn’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or organisation that will profit from this text, and has disclosed no related affiliations past their educational appointment.