shutterstock

COVID-19 continues to wreak havoc on retailers. Since robust new restrictions have been launched in elements of the UK throughout October, footfall on excessive streets, purchasing centres and out-of-town retail parks has fallen: it’s now down 32% yr on yr, with regional cities bearing the brunt. Many retailers usually are not paying lease, and a few landlords are contemplating authorized motion.

However as dreadful as COVID-19 has been, retail had severe present issues. The fact is that there’s far an excessive amount of retail floorspace within the UK. Coping with it’s going to be one of many large challenges of this decade.

The retail crunch

Retail employs extra folks than some other UK sector – about 2.9 million, two-thirds of whom work for the 75 largest firms, turning over round £394 billion in 2019. Lately, these companies have been wrestling with greater workers prices on account of will increase within the minimal wage; greater enterprise charges (property taxes), particularly for big retailers in prime places; a weaker pound for the reason that Brexit vote of 2016, making imports dearer; and on-line competitors.

The UK already had the third highest degree of on-line purchasing on the planet earlier than COVID-19 (16% of whole retail spend, exceeded solely by China and South Korea). Now on-line has turn into much more highly effective, peaking in June at one-third of all UK retail gross sales. Wherever it settles, it will likely be greater than earlier than the pandemic.

UK on-line gross sales as a % of whole retail

ONS

Due to on-line purchasing and the opposite pressures on bodily retail, as a lot as 40% of store floorspace could also be completely surplus to necessities. That is about 42 million sq. metres, equal to 175 Westfield Londons, 227 Metrocentres or 284 Bluewater purchasing centres.

This helps to clarify why Intu, proprietor of huge purchasing centres like Gateshead’s Metrocentre, Manchester’s Arndale and Trafford Centres, and Birmingham’s Merry Hill, went into administration in June. A lot of its centres at the moment are being offered or transferred to new administration because the Intu Group is dismantled.

Different large landlords have struggled too. Hammerson (whose centres embrace Brent Cross, Birmingham Bullring and Bristol Cabot Circus), British Land (Sheffield Meadowhall and Drake Circus in Plymouth) and Land Securities (Bluewater in Kent, Leeds White Rose and Buchanan Road in Glasgow) have been on a inventory market rollercoaster and face an analogous dilemma with their oversupply of retail floorspace.

Share costs of main UK retail landlords

Blue = British Land, Purple = Land Securities, Turquoise = Hammerson.

Buying and selling View

Mitigating components

One silver lining of the pandemic has been landlords having to reframe their relationship with tenants. As proposed by the UK authorities’s voluntary code of follow, which got here out in June, landlords should work with retailers for everybody to outlive this era. This consists of slicing rents to extra sustainable ranges.

For instance, the market is seeing a return to turnover rents, the place tenants pay a proportion of turnover relatively than a nominal “market” lease unrelated to prevailing financial circumstances. Such flexibility could scale back empty floorspace to a sure extent.

One other mitigating issue is that the majority retailers will nonetheless need some form of presence on excessive streets or purchasing centres. Certainly, the lockdown noticed a giant shift in home spending to native comfort and neighbourhood shops within the suburbs.

Retailers have additionally been mixing conventional and on-line gross sales by encouraging clients to order for next-day residence supply or click on and acquire. This offers them another excuse to retain a bodily presence. On the similar time, on-line retailers akin to Amazon are opening excessive avenue shops to enhance their providing.

The best way forward

Regardless of these improvements, there’s nonetheless more likely to be a big surplus of bodily shops total. So what could be finished?

Some area is likely to be used as workplaces, although the pandemic has seen an enormous rise in distant employees, a few of whom could by no means resume the workplace commute. Making shops into cinemas, eating places or bowling alleys is hardly an answer both, when the leisure sector is among the many hardest hit by pandemic restrictions.

Maybe the best alternative is to redevelop for a extra diversified mixture of complementary makes use of – as echoed by main retailer Invoice Grimsey’s name to “construct again higher”.

In cities and metropolis centres, this might embrace universities and schools increasing their campuses; galleries, workshops and showrooms for the humanities and artistic sector; group enterprises and hubs; and well being and wellbeing companies which will probably be important within the publish COVID period, akin to social care and psychological well being. Such makes use of might be assisted by public funding and landlords recognising that some tenants paying low rents are higher than no tenants in any respect.

Some redundant buildings and vacant higher flooring is also become properties – echoing the return to city residing of the 1990s and noughties. The federal government might reintroduce the residing over the store (LOTS) scheme, which subsidised such conversions throughout that period.

But many buildings don’t simply lend themselves to residential use. Utilities could wrestle to supply refuse assortment, water and sewerage connections, and parking areas. Planning relaxations could typically take away the necessity for planning permission to vary to residential use, however there are nonetheless advanced constructing rules, particularly relating to hearth safety and emergency entry.

Conventional excessive streets even have a number of house owners, who don’t all the time cooperate. City centre managers and enterprise enchancment districts (BIDs) will help right here, although we could must see BIDs that levy further enterprise charges on landlords relatively than tenants, like in Germany, to convey landlords to the negotiating desk.

Purchasing centres at the very least have the benefit of a single proprietor. As locations in their very own proper, they’re usually regarded (rightly or wrongly) as too large to fail, significantly these woven into the material of metropolis centres, akin to Liverpool One or Eldon Sq. in Newcastle. Conserving them functioning will subsequently be a excessive precedence for the authorities.

Some out-of-town purchasing centres had plans for brand spanking new residential and leisure developments even earlier than the pandemic. An instance is the undertaking to construct 2,000 new properties across the Gateshead Metrocentre. The concept could be to reorientate the centre, diversifying the combo of makes use of to serve a wider group, although it received’t be straightforward to create new household properties in an surroundings designed across the automobile.

Such challenges usually are not significantly new: 25 years in the past we might have referred to as it “mixed-use regeneration”. This time it’s pushed by extra retail area, paradoxically a lot of it constructed on the previous industrial websites that have been regenerated within the 1980s and 1990s.

Paul Michael Greenhalgh doesn’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or group that will profit from this text, and has disclosed no related affiliations past their tutorial appointment.